A Blog For Mums
Crumpets feel like one of those quietly comforting foods that sit somewhere between a treat and a staple. They’re warm, soft, a bit spongy, and very easy to justify at breakfast or tea time. But if you’re trying to feed yourself and your family reasonably well, it’s fair to wonder where they actually stand nutritionally. Are crumpets healthy, or are they just another beige carb pretending to be wholesome?
The honest answer, as with most foods, is that it depends how you look at them and how often they appear on your plate.
Traditional shop-bought crumpets are made from fairly simple ingredients: white wheat flour, water, yeast, salt, and a raising agent. That’s it. No hidden sugars, no oils, no long list of additives in most standard brands.
From a nutrition point of view, that means crumpets are mainly a source of carbohydrates. One standard crumpet usually contains around 90 to 100 calories, with very little fat and a modest amount of protein. They’re also low in sugar, which often surprises people who assume they’re closer to pancakes or pastries.
The downside is that most crumpets are made with refined white flour, which means they’re lower in fibre than wholegrain breads. Fibre is what helps keep you full, supports digestion, and slows down blood sugar spikes, so this is where crumpets lose a few health points.
Because crumpets are made from white flour, they’re digested fairly quickly. That means they can cause a faster rise in blood sugar compared to wholemeal toast or porridge oats.
If you eat a crumpet on its own, especially first thing in the morning, you might find you’re hungry again not long after. This doesn’t make crumpets unhealthy as such, but it does mean they’re not the most sustaining option by themselves.
This is where toppings matter a lot more than people realise.
A plain crumpet is basically a blank canvas. What you put on it can turn it into a balanced snack or push it firmly into treat territory.
Butter is the classic choice, and while it’s often demonised, a thin scrape of butter isn’t a nutritional disaster. It adds fat, which actually helps slow digestion and keeps you fuller for longer. The problem is when thin scrape quietly becomes thick layer.
Jam, honey, and chocolate spreads turn crumpets into a sugar hit. Again, nothing wrong occasionally, but not ideal if you’re eating them daily.
More balanced toppings make a big difference. Peanut butter, cream cheese, eggs, or even a bit of smashed avocado add protein and healthy fats. That combination helps stabilise blood sugar and makes a crumpet feel more like a proper meal rather than a snack that disappears too quickly.
For children, crumpets can be a perfectly reasonable option. They’re soft, easy to chew, and generally well tolerated by fussy eaters. They also tend to be lower in sugar than many breakfast cereals marketed at kids, which is a point in their favour.
That said, the same rules apply. Pairing a crumpet with protein or fat helps avoid the energy crash that can come after a refined-carb-heavy breakfast. Adding a boiled egg, yoghurt, or nut butter on the side can make a big difference to how long it keeps them going.
If you’re packing a crumpet into a lunchbox, it’s worth thinking of it as part of a meal rather than the whole thing.
Not all crumpets are created equal. Wholemeal versions contain more fibre and tend to be more filling. Sourdough-style crumpets, which are becoming more common, may also be easier to digest for some people and have a slightly gentler effect on blood sugar.
If crumpets are something you eat often, choosing one of these options can quietly improve the nutritional value without changing the comfort factor.
This is a common comparison, and nutritionally they’re not worlds apart. A slice of white toast and a crumpet are very similar in calories and carbohydrate content. Wholemeal toast usually comes out slightly ahead because of its fibre content.
Where crumpets sometimes lose out is portion awareness. It’s very easy to eat two or three crumpets without thinking, especially when they’re warm and dripping with butter. Toast tends to feel more obviously like individual slices.
Being mindful of portions matters more than labelling one food as good and another as bad.
Crumpets sit firmly in the middle ground. They’re not a superfood, but they’re also not junk. They’re low in sugar, relatively low in fat, and made from simple ingredients. Their main limitation is the lack of fibre and protein, which means they’re best paired with more filling foods.
If you enjoy crumpets occasionally, or even regularly as part of a balanced meal, there’s no real reason to avoid them. Like so many comfort foods, they work best when they’re not doing all the nutritional heavy lifting on their own.
Warm, familiar, and quietly reassuring, crumpets can still have a place at the table. They just don’t need to be pretending to be something they’re not.
Self Care and Health
